In the mid ‘70s, the United Bethel Mennonite and Shiloh Mennonite congregations began discussions about starting a Christian school. On January 8, 1978, the two churches elected a school board. Ralph Cooley (chairman), Joseph Beachy (assistant chairman), and members, Bill Helmuth, John Miller, Eli Gingerich, and Crist Mast composed the first school board. Under the leadership of the ministers, Walter Beachy, Leroy Yoder, David Showalter and Allen Yutzy, the board began to formulate plans. Beginning discussions for the location of the school included a number of options such as buying the Monroe school building.
In May of 1978, Don Showalter accepted the position of principal for the new school. After deciding to build, on August 24, 1978, the school board contacted Eli C. Beachy about purchasing land. Eli sold and partially donated 9 ½ acres of land for $9000. Alvin Kramer sold additional property for $3000 an acre. Bill Helmuth drew up plans and headed up the project.
On June 28, 1978, at a meeting at United Bethel, a name which means God’s glory, Shekinah Christian School, was chosen. The school board made the decision to use the A.C.E. curriculum.
Ninety-three students arrived for the first day of school on September 6, 1978. For the first two years until the new school building was finished, classes met at the United Bethel Mennonite using the church building along with modular classrooms. Staff members were Don Showalter, Mary Farmwald, Regina Nisly, Susan Hartman, Oneita Yutzy, Conrad Mayer, Kathy Miller and Susan Budke. Andrew Gingerich was the first custodian.
A ground-breaking service was held on Sunday, July 15, 1979, at 2:30 p.m. After many hours of donated labor on the part of Bill Helmuth and many others, the school building at 10040 Lafayette-P.C. Rd. became a reality, opening for school in August of 1980. The administration did a survey about the individualized curriculum and the board discussed making some changes.
In the fall of 1991, the first Kindergarten class began at Shekinah as a conventionally taught class using the BJU curriculum. That year 1st-5th also was taught conventionally. In the next three years the grade levels were added until grades K-8 were all using conventionally- taught curriculum. The high school students continued with the individualized, self-paced structure except for math, Spanish and music, all conventionally taught classes.
In 2011, the school board began making plans to restructure the high school curriculum. At the beginning of the 2013-2014 school year, the Learning Center became a library/study hall. To add classroom space the school board purchased two modular buildings, and Shekinah made the transition from ACE to conventionally taught classes.
A four-classroom modular building was added in 2022 as enrollment increased to 142 full-time students breaking the 2009 record of 139 full-time students. Shekinah became chartered by the State of Ohio Department of Education and Workforce on January 31, 2024, making the EdChoice scholarship an option for Shekinah students.
In May of 2024, Shekinah completed its 46th year and graduated its 45th graduating class, bringing the total number of graduates to 442. Current enrollment is 200 full-time K-12 students.